I can’t tell you enough how SUPER EXCITED I am that Harry Connick Jr.’s mentoring the American Idol Top 5 tonight! Harry has been one of my favorites for years & years. I was even devastated when Harry married his wife☺. I mean, he could’ve waited for me! But I understand…she was a Victoria’s Secret model, lol! For the newbies, Harry was the precursor to Michael Buble. But seriously, he’s extremely talented & the Idols are lucky to have the chance to work with him. Not only did he mentor them, but he arranged their performances & will be accompanying them on piano during their live performances with some of his band members.
Harry’s perfect to mentor the Idols as they sing songs from The Frank Sinatra Songbook. The old standards that Harry sings & that Frank sang are some of my favorite songs ever. This is a special night for me! Btw, Sinatra’s daughters Nancy & Tina were in the audience tonight and they had a special gift for Simon! Turns out, Simon’s a big Frank Sinatra fan, so they were so kind to bring him their Dad’s “F.A.S.” monogrammed hanky…how exciting is that?!
Aaron Kelly: Harry’s always been a funny & playful guy, so he had jokes when Aaron 1st walked in the room…he yelled out, ‘Big Mike!’, lol! Aaron’s singing “Fly Me To The Moon”…completely awesome song! Harry gave him advice on transitioning from a note to fit the chords being played by the band. He says he really likes Aaron & that he’s got such a sweet voice. Harry’s right, Aaron’s got a sweet voice. He doesn’t sound bad singing this song. But to be singing a song with such hopeful & playful lyrics about love, his demeanor onstage was just way too serious for me. He sounded decent though. Randy thought he did a really good job. Ellen joked that she thought the piano was a little pitchy, which got a big laugh from Harry, lol! Ellen thought he really pulled the performance off & had beautiful vocals. Kara thought it was good, but thinks it wasn’t as strong compared to last week. Kara suggested that Aaron learn a little more charisma & how to fill up the stage. I guess that was a little along the lines of what I mentioned. He really needs to interpret the words of the song better. His facial expressions & presence onstage just didn’t match the message of the song in my opinion. But Kara did say that she expected to see Aaron still on the show next week. Simon mentioned that he’ll treasure his Sinatra hanky for the rest of his life! He said that he adored Frank because he was the king of cool with a swagger & a believability. He said that if Frank was a lion, Aaron was just a mouse. Again, along the same line of thought that I mentioned. These kids have it hard tonight because we’re gonna be thinking about Frank Sinatra with every note they try to hit & with every step they take onstage. Frank’s singing was amazing & his stage presence was full of confidence. But Simon ended by saying that Aaron tries hard and that’s why people like him.
Casey James: Casey says he’s been listening to Harry his whole life, so it was totally awesome to work with him! Casey chose to sing “Blue Skies.” Of all the contestants, I worried this week that Casey’s bluesy sound wouldn’t do well with singing these old standards. But Harry said that he thought Casey would do great. He said that it doesn’t seem to be about the lyrics with Casey, but it’s about being the vehicle for his blues. That’s odd to say since lyrics are so important to the song & a singer’s interpretation of them. But I trust Harry’s instincts & musical opinions because he’s so brilliant musically. He says that sometimes it’s not about the lyrics, but about the groove. I have to say that after his performance…I was pleasantly surprised that Casey didn’t sound terrible! I mean, it was nothing near to how Sinatra would sound, but it wasn’t horrendous. Randy thought it was Casey’s worst performance, wow. Ellen thought the performance was very stiff. Kara said that it took Casey a long time to relax, but that at least he held some good notes. But then she said he sounded like a lamb…I don’t think that’s a compliment! Simon said that Casey wasn’t fantastic & that he came across as embarrassed and a bit awkward. Btw, Harry mentioned that Casey sang the song better in rehearsals earlier in the night. Wow, rough judging session for Casey.
~Sidebar~ Sir Anthony Hopkins was in the Idol audience 2nite!
Crystal Bowersox: Singing “Summer Wind.” I love Nat “King” Cole’s version of this song. Harry said that what he liked about Crystal’s interpretation was that she was singing about something personal. He actually didn’t have much mentoring advice for Crystal because he felt that she was already ready. Huge compliment! And she looked beautiful with her updo & her black, lacy evening gown! Crystal not only looked the part, but she sang the song well. Her voice sounded great with the big band…the music didn’t over power her. She sang strong when the band got big & she sang soft & tender when the song called for it. She was just great. She could’ve fit right into a smoky piano bar singing jazz tunes! And although we’re used to comparing her to Melissa Etheridge & Bonnie Raitt, Crystal showed that she’s versatile enough to sing the old standards too! And all along, she remained true to who she is as an artist because she made the song hers! And that’s why you gotta love Crystal Bowersox! Randy thought it was just okay & a little sleepy for him. Ellen wanted her to loosen up more, but said that Crystal has so many different sides to her, that it’s really impressive. Kara said that it was out of Crystal’s element, but she kind of liked it because she had great phrasing. Simon loved the song, but wasn’t sure if he would’ve chosen it for Crystal. He said the 1st half was too jazzy, but the 2nd half was better. The judges weren’t as impressed with her as I was!
Michael Lynche: Singing “The Way You Look Tonight.” Harry says that this is one of his favorite songs. He suggests that with a song as wonderful as this, you don’t have to mess with the melody too much. He told Michael to think about his wife when he sings this song so that the words are true for him. Michael sounded lovely, as usual. It’s funny how every time he starts singing another line, Big Mike has to lick his lips! Lol, watch out LL Cool J! Randy thought that Harry’s arrangement was unbelievable and that Big Mike’s vocals were unbelievable! Ellen says that Mike seems to have the most confidence onstage compared to the other contestants. She said he looked the part, he sounded the part, he had lots of charisma, smoothness & was very good. Kara said that Mike found the drama in the song…he took us up, he took us down & took us on a journey. She said he did everything right, including not losing himself in the song. Simon said that the 1st three performances were just okay, but that Big Mike’s performance was better. He said that everything worked, was fantastic & well done!
Lee Dewyze: Singing “That’s Life.” Harry says that he likes Lee a lot & that his wife thinks he’s really cute! He joked that Lee is a new & improved version of him! The advice Harry had for Lee was to make sure he emphasized certain words in the song while singing them so that the audience really knows the story of what he’s been through. Lee sounded pretty good singing this song. It was a good song choice for him, but I wish that his stage presence was a little more commanding. The song was a good fit for his personality though. Randy loved Lee’s performance. Ellen said that if this was the last night of performances, Lee would’ve just won the whole thing. Hmm, I wouldn’t agree with that because Big Mike’s stage presence & vocals were better than Lee’s. Kara thought the performance was amazing & suggested that Lee practice believing that he can win the contest. Simon said that Harry brought out Lee’s personality & his confidence. Simon thought it was the best performance of the night.
It was a great evening! Harry was the most fun & informative mentor so far this season & I can’t wait to see him performing on Idol 2morrow night. Lady Gaga will also return to the Idol stage 2morrow. Going strictly from the judges’ comments, Casey, Aaron & Crystal may wind up in the Bottom 3. And if I were a betting woman, I’d say Casey will be the one going home. Aaron would be my next choice to go home. Results Show is tomorrow.








































































